Thomas Perry

Barrister and Solicitor

Thomas Perry is an employment and labour lawyer in Toronto, Ontario. He has experience with management-side employment and labour issues, and providing strategic HR advice to businesses.

He can be reached at thomasperry88@gmail.com

Any information provided should be considered for entertainment purposes only and is not legal advice. You should seek independent legal advice before making any decisions. Use of this website does not create a client relationship.

Workplace Investigations 101: Best Practices for Ontario Employers

By

Workplace investigations are a critical tool for addressing employee complaints, resolving disputes, and maintaining a safe and respectful work environment. In Ontario, employers have a legal obligation to investigate certain issues, such as harassment, discrimination, and workplace violence, under the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) and the Human Rights Code. A poorly conducted investigation can lead to legal liability, reputational damage, and employee dissatisfaction. This article outlines best practices for conducting fair, thorough, and legally compliant workplace investigations.

When is an Investigation Required?

Employers must investigate in the following situations:

  1. Harassment or Discrimination Complaints:
    • Under the Human Rights Code, employers must address complaints of harassment or discrimination based on protected grounds, such as race, gender, or disability.
  2. Workplace Violence or Harassment:
    • The OHSA requires employers to investigate incidents or complaints of workplace violence or harassment.
  3. Serious Misconduct:
    • Allegations of theft, fraud, or other serious misconduct should be investigated to determine the facts and take appropriate action.
  4. Whistleblower Complaints:
    • Complaints about unethical or illegal behavior, such as health and safety violations, must be taken seriously and investigated.

Step-by-Step Guide to Conducting a Workplace Investigation

1. Plan the Investigation

  • Determine the scope and objectives of the investigation.
  • Appoint an impartial investigator, either internally (e.g., HR professional) or externally (e.g., third-party investigator).
  • Develop an investigation plan, including a timeline and list of witnesses to interview.

2. Gather Evidence

  • Collect relevant documents, such as emails, policies, and performance records.
  • Preserve physical evidence, if applicable (e.g., damaged property).

3. Conduct Interviews

  • Interview the complainant, the respondent, and any witnesses.
  • Ask open-ended questions to gather detailed information.
  • Maintain confidentiality to protect privacy and prevent retaliation.

4. Analyze the Evidence

  • Review all evidence to determine what happened and whether policies were violated.
  • Assess the credibility of the parties and witnesses.

5. Prepare a Report

  • Document the investigation process, findings, and conclusions.
  • Include recommendations for corrective action, if necessary.

6. Take Action

  • Implement appropriate corrective measures, such as disciplinary action, training, or policy changes.
  • Communicate the outcome to the complainant and respondent, while respecting privacy.

7. Follow Up

  • Monitor the workplace to ensure the issue has been resolved and no retaliation has occurred.
  • Provide support to affected employees, such as access to an Employee Assistance Program (EAP).

Best Practices for Workplace Investigations

  1. Act Promptly:
    • Start the investigation as soon as possible to demonstrate that the complaint is being taken seriously.
  2. Be Impartial:
    • Ensure the investigator is neutral and has no conflict of interest.
  3. Maintain Confidentiality:
    • Limit knowledge of the investigation to those who need to be involved.
  4. Document Everything:
    • Keep detailed records of the investigation process, including notes from interviews and evidence collected.
  5. Communicate Clearly:
    • Inform the complainant and respondent about the investigation process and timeline.
  6. Avoid Retaliation:
    • Ensure that no adverse actions are taken against the complainant or witnesses for participating in the investigation.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  1. Delaying the Investigation:
    • Delays can undermine the credibility of the investigation and lead to claims of negligence.
  2. Failing to Be Thorough:
    • A rushed or incomplete investigation can result in incorrect conclusions and legal liability.
  3. Ignoring Procedural Fairness:
    • Ensure that both the complainant and respondent are given an opportunity to present their side of the story.
  4. Overlooking Follow-Up:
    • Failing to monitor the workplace after the investigation can lead to recurring issues or retaliation claims.

Case Law Highlights

  1. Shah v. Xerox Canada Ltd.:
    • The HRTO found that the employer failed to properly investigate a harassment complaint, resulting in a finding of discrimination and a substantial damages award.
  2. Bubb-Clark v. Toronto Transit Commission:
    • The court emphasized the importance of taking complaints seriously and conducting thorough investigations.
  3. Laskowska v. Marineland of Canada Inc.:
    • The court ruled that the employer’s failure to investigate a harassment complaint contributed to a toxic work environment, leading to a significant damages award.

Conclusion

Workplace investigations are a critical tool for addressing employee complaints and maintaining a safe and respectful work environment. By following best practices, such as acting promptly, maintaining impartiality, and documenting the process, employers can ensure fair and legally compliant investigations. When in doubt, seek legal advice to navigate complex issues and protect your organization’s interests.